Online Shop
Order online through PayPal or you can call us to order. Call us at (932) 323‐3151 (Office) or (937) 322‐PIES (Bakery) Monday through Friday between 9A.M. and 5P.M. EST
Note: All payments are processed through PayPal, but you are not required to have a PayPal account.
All orders must be over $50 before we ship. Learn more about how we ship your pie ›
Our Products
Sweet Potato Pie - $13.00
Made with fresh sweet potatoes, lots of butter, cream and eggs. A great creamy texture and homemade crust. Flavors: Original & Lemon Sweet Potato. Order now ›
9" Deep - Serves 6-8
Pumpkin Pie - $11.00
Everyone’s favorite during the holiday get together or enjoy anytime. Hooray for the pumpkin pie! Order now ›
9" Deep - Serves 6-8
Pecan Pie - $13.00
Our pecan pie is perfect for any occasion. It is full of plump pecans and buttery flavor. A traditional southern favorite, no matter how you pronounce it... Order now ›
9" Deep - Serves 6-8
Apple Pie - $13.00
This all American pie is made with Ida red apples and has a woven lattice crust designed to allow all the natural juices to bubble through. Order now ›
9" Deep - Serves 6-8
Cherry Pie - $13.00
Just the right balance of sweet and tangy, and full of plump red cherries. Why would George cut a cherry tree down? To pick cherries for a simply delicious Parolee Pie! Order now ›
9" Deep - Serves 6-8
Classic Peach Pie - $13.00
Made with juicy ripe yellow peaches nestled between our tender crusts. Heat it up, add a dollop of whipped cream and enjoy. Order now ›
9" Deep - Serves 6-8
Deep Dish Kentucky Cobblers
Blackberry Cobbler - $29.00
The Deep Dish Kentucky Blackberry Cobbler is second to none in or out of the Derby… We have crowned it with our handmade flaky crust, layers of fresh plump blackberries, and real butter. Our daddy’s favorite. Order now ›
10"x10" Extra Deep Pan - Serves 6-8
Cherry Cobbler - $29.00
Deep Dish Kentucky Cherry Cobbler will always put a smile on your face. Not too tart but sweetened just right to ask for seconds. It kind of reminds me of those juicy cherries on the tree in our neighbor’s back yard we could never get enough of. Order now ›
10"x10" Extra Deep Pan - Serves 6-8
Apple Cobbler - $29.00
You can almost smell the fresh baked aroma of our Ida Red Apples and cinnamon by just thinking about out Deep Dish Apple Cobbler. It is Aunt Wilma’s favorite with a piping hot cup of coffee. Order now ›
10"x10" Extra Deep Pan - Serves 6-8
Peach Cobbler - $29.00
Our Deep Dish Peach Cobbler Is our Number One best seller. It is so good, that we needed to show the juicy, buttery, and peachy inside view. Our Kentucky Peach cobbler gets the "Gold" every time it is served! Order now ›
10"x10" Extra Deep Pan - Serves 6-8